HP- applying new design direction to bumper ticket (previously was loyalty card),

BUMPER TICKET.
My idea for this ticket was that it would be a card that you can buy at the start of the Potter Month, that admits you to all of the showings.
This was my original design idea - I thought about having the scars spot varnished.
However, thinking about what Lorenzo said, is this creative enough? IS IT MEMORABLE?

 

How the ticket would look at the end, all 8 rectangles clipped out, making it look like a piece of film strip.

 

Yellow background, cut around the text? The same style as the limited edition posters?

 

FRONT OF THE CARD, larger scars, across it, with 'potter card'.

 

a white card? with yellow scars placed in different ways on the card? still seems boring? Maybe it's because I have been staring at them all for too long? I just don't think any of them are as strong as they could be? 

 

I thought that instead of the rectangles being clipped out, they could already be clipped out at the start, give the ticket some depth? Texture? The numbers could be stamped?

 

How the ticket could look? 

BACK

 

FRONT 

 

NUMBERS DON'T WORK. 

Just scars??

NOT SURE IF I LIKE ANY OF THESE?

indecisive again, 

should I be designing individual tickets?